Mets voice frustration as top pitching target snubs them after last-minute change of heart

The New York Mets wanted to bring back left-handed pitcher Steven Matz, who pitched the first six seasons of his big league career with them.

While the Mets were keen on securing his signature, the hurler reportedly had a last-minute change of heart and his agent failed to come back to them after the St. Louis Cardinals made him a four-year, $44 million offer he ended up accepting.

“(The) Mets are upset about the Matz situation and his last minute call to Cardinals. They had the impression he was going to come back to them for a final chance. Sources say Mets would have gone to that level ($44M, 4 years)”, MLB Network’s Jon Heyman explained via Twitter.

Matz had a fantastic 2021 campaign, with a 14-7 record, a 3.82 ERA. A 1.33 WHIP, and 144 strikeouts in 150.2 innings.

The Mets’ owner was an unhappy man this morning

“I’m not happy this morning. I’ve never seen such unprofessional behavior exhibited by a player’s agent. I guess words and promises don’t matter”, Mets’ owner Steve Cohen tweeted this morning, presumably about the Matz situation.

Matz’ market heated up this week, and it was clear he would sign before Thanksgiving. Lots of teams were behind his services, including the Jays, Mets, Cardinals, and many more.

Jeff Passan of ESPN reports that Matz can make up to $48 million and will receive a signing bonus.

The Mets badly need rotation help after losing Noah Syndergaard to the Los Angeles Angels, and with Marcus Stroman currently a free agent, their depth consists of Jacob deGrom, Carlos Carrasco, Taijuan Walker, Tylor Megill, and David Peterson. They need at least two or three arms, and were determined to bring back Matz after his one-year stint in Toronto.

However, it wasn’t meant to be, and the Mets will have to keep monitoring the market while they look for improvements. The Billy Eppler era didn’t start on the right foot, but there is still plenty of time to build a competitive roster.

2021 New York Mets Player Evaluations: First Baseman Pete Alonso

mets, pete alonso

In a year where the New York Mets offense completely abandoned the team, Pete Alonso was the one player who kept chugging along in the middle of the order. Alonso’s power made up just under 20% of the Mets home run total for the entire 2021 season.

Alonso came off a disappointing 2020 season where his average took a dramatic dip. He was more consistent with his average during the first half of the season, but his average still was not at his level of expectations. The same could be said for his power numbers. Alonso had a .477 slugging percentage at the All-Star break with 17 homers and 49 runs batted in. Those numbers would be terrific for most players, but Alonso’s rookie season set the bar high, and Alonso did not make the All-Star team.

His improved pitch recognition helped lower his strikeout rate to below 20%, making him even more of a dangerous hitter. Despite not playing in the ASG, Alonso traveled to Coors Field to defend his Home Run Derby crown. Like Steph Curry in the three-point contest, Alonso made the derby look easy and won his second crown. Competing in the derby also allowed him to rekindle his power stroke for the second half of the season.

Lone Brightspot

Alonso ended up carrying his derby dominance into the second half and played at an all-star level. He slashed .275/.361/.560 with 20 home runs and even found a way to hit three triples. Alonso finished the year with 27 doubles, three triples, and 37 home runs. His slash line was on par with his rookie season and only struck out 127 times in 152 games. Alonso turned into a matured hitter this season and showed he is way more than a one-dimensional power threat.

His baseball savant page is one to be in awe of as he sits at the top of plenty of categories. His average exit velocity (80th percentile), hard-hit rate (81st percentile), and barrel rate (89th percentile) all contributed to his successful season. One of the biggest reasons for the turnaround was Alonso’s ability to hit breaking balls. In 2020, Alonso batted .191 and slugged .397 compared to a much more respectable .223 and .549 this season.

The one point of emphasis for Alonso’s offseason is leveling off his swing to avoid being weak on high strikes. Becoming a consistent hitter on pitches up will allow his average to creep closer to .300. Pitching Alonso up in the zone was a high-risk, high-reward move. His average across the top quadrants were .273 (inside), .706 (middle), and .429 (outside), showing you had to get the ball inside to beat him. On the flip side, his whiff rate hovered around 30% in all three spots.

Respectable Defense

The biggest knock on Alonso was his defense, but those questions have become irrelevant. For the first time in his career, Alonso posted a positive (2) outs above average and his defensive runs saved of five was a career-high. The one spot of improvement will come in his ability to make better decision-making on balls to his right. Alonso would often drift for balls better suited for the second baseman, making a play harder than it seems. His OAA of -6 on balls toward third base and four on balls towards first base show the vast difference in his range.

2022 will be a massive year for Alonso as the Mets need him to continue leading this offense loaded with questions marks. The progressions over the last three seasons should set expectations towards another 40 home run season. Surrounding Alonso with at least one more power bat can help his cause towards another 50 home run season.

2021 Grades On 20-80 Scale (2022 Projection)

Hitting: 55 (60), .270 xBA was the highest of his career.

Power: 75 (80), 37 homers were third in the NL.

Run: 25 (25), Sprint speed has decreased every year but hit three triples this season.

Arm: 50 (50), Only three throwing errors, and he started four double plays.

Field: 40 (50), Alonso has become a solid defensive first baseman; look for that to continue to improve.

Overall: 65 (70), Betting on Alonso to win MVP in 2022 is a long shot but not a bad bet.

Mets lose star reliever Aaron Loup, but focus on starting pitching instead

Simeon Woods-Richardson

Aaron Loup, who had a historic 2021 season with the New York Mets on a one-year deal, left for the Los Angeles Angels after signing a two-year, $17 million deal with an option for 2024. It’s hefty sum to pay for the 33-year-old, but the Halos are determined to solve their pitching woes and giving Mike Trout, Shohei Ohtani, and company a chance at a deep playoff run.

In fact, Loup is the second high-profile free agent that the Angels steal away from the Mets, after they signed Noah Syndergaard to a one-year, $21 million deal a few days ago.

Loup was brilliant in a Mets uniform this season, with a 0.95 ERA, a 2.45 FIP, and 1.6 Wins Above Replacement (WAR) in 56.2 frames. He struck out 26.1% of the hitters he faced and earned a very solid 50.4% groundball rate.

New Mets’ general manager Billy Eppler couldn’t do much to stop Loup from signing with the Angels, because he was, according to SNY, already deep in talks with Los Angeles when the new executive assumed his role in New York.

The Mets want to add starters

Also according to SNY, once the Mets realized what Loup’s market was, they chose to continue to focus on starters. Their rotation depth is extremely thin: at the moment, Jacob deGrom, Taijuan Walker, David Peterson, Tylor Megill, and Carlos Carrasco are the top starters, and there are injury questions surrounding most of them.

For the Mets, retaining Marcus Stroman and adding to the overall depth is perhaps more important than Loup. There are plenty of options in the reliever free agent market, too, and Loup was bound to regress a little in 2022.

The lack of a new CBA agreement between owners and players will likely result in offseason transactions being frozen from December 1 until both parties can reach a deal, so lots of free agent deals are expected to be completed in November.

2021 New York Mets Player Evaluations: Catcher James McCann

The New York Mets opted for the cheaper option last offseason when they opted to sign James McCann instead of J.T. Realmuto. McCann signed with the Mets for four years at $40.6 million while Realmuto inked a five-year, $115.5 million deal with the rival Philadelphia Phillies. These were the best two catching options in free agency, but McCann lagged behind Realmuto in 2021.

McCann was such an intriguing addition because of his emerging hitting metrics, which showed increased exit velocity and launch angle, which was not present early in his career. He seemed like a much better option than Wilson Ramos but was more of the same. McCann had an extremely slow start as his average hovered around the Mendoza line through the end of May.

False Hope

When June rolled around, he put together his best offensive month by hitting .288/.341/.500 with four home runs and 16 runs batted in. McCann never carried the momentum to the second half of the season and finished was a slash line of .232/.294/.349 in 121 games. These numbers would be no surprise the Mets signed the Detroit Tigers version of McCann, but they invested in the Chicago White Sox version.

In Chicago, McCann became a hitter known for his increased hard-hit rate and launch angle. While the hard-hit remained similar, his launch angle fell dramatically. McCann’s launch angle dropped from 15 degrees in 2020 to just 9.3 in the 2021 season. This resulted in his 51.7% groundball rate, the highest of his career, and grounding into 12 double plays. McCann’s hard-hit groundballs combined with his lack of speed make it impossible for him to be a steady hitter.

Defensive Steps Back

McCann was solid behind the plate but was not as good as advertised. He threw out a career-low 27% of base stealers, but the Mets expected more since his career rate was in the mid-30s. Pitch framing was below average at -3 runs extra strikes and a 47.9% strike rate. The reason for the drop-off from 2020 was McCann’s inability to frame pitches low in the zone. From inside to outside to a right-handed batter, he had a percentage of 38.1%/61.8%/31.3% last season. In 2021, McCann fell to 24%/51.6%/29.9%, and we would often see him give up on the lower pitches as the season moved forward.

The biggest concern for McCann was his inability to hit high velocity after making a name off it during last season. He hit .245 with a .371 slugging percentage off fastballs this season after hitting .326 with a .478 slugging the previous year. McCann often struggled with his timing at the plate and never looked comfortable at any point.

He should bounce back fine defensively, but the bat is a significant question mark heading into 2022. McCann is heading into his age-32 season at a position where regressions steadily decline at his age. He was never a factor on offense and is heading into a critical year in year two of his deal.

Catching prospect Francisco Alvarez is a projected 2023 debut and is quickly on his way to becoming big-league ready. Should each of them continue to move in opposite directions, we could discuss Alvarez as the opening day catcher in 2023. Tomas Nido is a present member of the Mets roster who is on McCann’s heels to take away playing time. Nido had a few stretches where he earned playing time over the struggling McCann.

2021 Grades On 20-80 Scale (2022 Projection)

Hitting: 30 (35), .232 average is eight points lower than his average during five years in Detroit.

Power: 25 (35), The power numbers are more likely to return than the average.

Run: 20 (20), 26.7 sprint speed was a 0.6 increase from 2020.

Arm: 40 (50), 1 rSB and his 27% CS will improve in 2022.

Field: 30 (45), -5 DRS, and eight passed balls were the second-highest of his career.

Overall: 30 (40), Even as a Tiger, McCann was a better player than he showed in 2021.

3 potential trade targets for the Mets

New York Yankees, Luis Castillo

The New York Mets have several positions to address during the offseason if they want to have a shot at taking first place in the NL East division in 2022. While the next step would be appointing a manager, they are still monitoring the market to look for roster upgrades.

Their most pressing needs are center field, a third baseman, and pitching, both for the rotation and the bullpen. Free agency is an obvious avenue to bring players, but the trade market is also an option.

These three players, potentially available via trade, would fit in the Mets with ease.

Byron Buxton, CF, Minnesota Twins

Buxton would represent a huge upgrade in center field for the Mets. It would also be a direct replacement for free agent Michael Conforto, because the team would slide Brandon Nimmo to a corner and plug Buxton in the middle.

Buxton put an amazing .306/.358/.647 line with 4.2 Wins Above Replacement, or WAR, which is amazing considering he only participated in 61 games. He is injury-prone, sure, but remains one of the game’s best all-around players and would fit in the Mets like a glove.

Matt Chapman, 3B, Oakland A’s

The Mets have been looking for a reliable third baseman for a while. They have had to play JD Davis there, and while he can hit, he struggles to stay healthy and is a liability on the field. Chapman, on the other hand, is a magician with the glove.

Additionally, he carries severe power in his right-handed bat. He hit 27 homers this season and his career-high is 36. However, he carries some batting-average risk by virtue of his high strikeout rate. Still, he is a 6-win player when at his best and could be a major upgrade for the Mets.

Luis Castillo, SP, Cincinnati Reds

The Cincinnati Reds have made it clear that they are not looking to shop Castillo. Still, it could be a move to maintain some leverage, and the Mets don’t lose anything if they knock on the door.

Castillo had a rough first two months of the season, but finished with a 3.98 ERA as a whole and a 2.73 mark from June to the end of the campaign.

The Mets need rotation help after losing Noah Syndergaard to the Los Angeles Angels and with Marcus Stroman still testing the free agent market.

Mets will take their time to hire the right manager, per new GM

The New York Mets recently welcomed their new general manager, Billy Eppler, after a long search that included no less than 10 candidates. He has extensive scouting experience and was the GM of the Los Angeles Angels from 2015 to 2020.

One of Eppler’s first things to do in his new position is finding a new manager to lead the Mets “for years to come”. Asked whether he would prefer a skipper with more analytics-based thinking or an old-schooler, he said:

“I’d love to find somebody that checks every single box and is great in all areas. It’s interesting that you bring it up, because over this past year just learning and reading and kind of re-thinking some of the ways that you approach things, I wanted to be able to sit down with the senior baseball ops group, and then sit down with Steve [Cohen] and Sandy [Alderson] and kind of all collectively talk about what kind of criteria we think might be important for the next manager of the Mets.

“I have a little bit of my own feeling on that, but I’d rather hold back on giving exactly what that criteria is at this moment in time because I want to have the group engaged. And get a sense of, do you value, for example, tactical in-game management as your primary criteria or primary element? Do you value analytic in-game probabilistic thinking as your No. 1 criteria? Or your ability to connect with the media and fan base, obviously that’s critical, and clubhouse culture.

The Mets are considering at least five names

SNY reported that the Mets are currently considering at least five names: Brad Ausmus, Joe Espada, Eric Chavez, John Farrell, and Buck Showalter.

However, Eppler told media over the weekend that he doesn’t anticipate a quick resolution, and thinks the Mets will take their time to pick the manager that will replace Luis Rojas.

“As far as the manager process, I don’t expect it to be done overnight or even be done in the next week,” Eppler said. “I know we’re about to embark on a holiday week. Starting to have those conversations and carve out time each day to meeting a candidate, I think could be done simultaneously, just as you manage your time.”

Mets lose pitcher Noah Syndergaard to this West Coast team

New York Mets, Noah Syndergaard

The New York Mets’ rotation plans for 2022 took a hit on Tuesday, when Noah Syndergaard accepted a one-year, $21 million contract offer from the Los Angeles Angels, thus rejecting New York’s $18.4 million qualifying offer.

The expectation all along was for Syndergaard to stay with the Mets in 2022, and then enter the market and pursue a long-term deal. But the Angels, led by general manager Perry Minasian, entered the equation and offered a better one-year deal to lure him to California.

The pact is still pending a physical, but it is expected to be a formality. The pitcher returned from a long absence related to Tommy John surgery and pitched a couple of games down the stretch, albeit only throwing fastball and changeups due to doctor recommendations.

He is expected to be able to use his full arsenal in 2022, though, so the Angels are getting a high-upside pitcher for just one year, minimizing the risk. The Mets, meanwhile, will get Los Angeles’ second-highest draft pick as compensation.

The Mets will miss Syndergaard

When healthy, ‘Thor’ is a dynamic talent. Still young at 29, he averaged 98 mph on his heater from 2015-19 with the Mets, and had a 3.31 ERA during that time. Over that span, he received Rookie of the Year votes (in 2015) and Cy Young votes.

Syndergaard boasts a complete arsenal, and can miss bats with four pitches: his high-90s fastball, a changeup, a curveball, and a slider. He will try to help the Angels get to the postseason for the first time since 2014, and he will have a formidable offense behind him, led by Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani.

The loss of Syndergaard (even though he was technically a free agent) is particularly painful for the Mets, since they are now down to Jacob deGrom, Carlos Carrasco, Taijuan Walker, David Peterson, and Tylor Megill as rotation depth.

Mets are finalizing deal to bring their new general manager: Billy Eppler

New York Mets

At long last, the New York Mets will finally have someone in charge of baseball decisions and running the team. Billy Eppler is reportedly finalizing a deal to become their new general manager, according to multiple sources including ESPN’s Jeff Passan and MLB Network’s Jon Heyman.

Eppler, 46, had accepted a position with William Morris Endeavor, which is a talent representation agency that recently ventured into the baseball world and had free agent shortstop Carlos Correa as its highest profile client. However, he will now take over the Mets, and the offseason, for them, can finally get started.

Eppler is best known for his time as the Los Angeles Angels’ general manager, which lasted from 2015 to 2020. He couldn’t deliver a playoff berth, but under his leadership, the Halos signed Mike Trout to an extension and brought two-way star Shohei Ohtani.

Before his stint with the Angels and joining the Mets, Eppler had spent 10 years with the Yankees, so he knows what it’s like to work in New York and deal with the huge expectations of a demanding fan base.

The Mets’ extensive search comes to an end

Before turning their attention to Eppler, the Mets had failed to convince at least 10 other candidates to join the team either as general manager or president of baseball operations.

David Stearns, Billy Beane, Theo Epstein, Billy Eppler, Matt Arnold, Raquel Ferreira, Michael Girsch, Jean Afterman, Scott Harris, Brandon Gomes, and Mark Shapiro were considered for the positions, but all of them turned them down, citing different reasons.

According to MLB Trade Rumors, Eppler broke into baseball as a scout with the Rockies in the early 2000s “before joining the Yankees in that same role. He was eventually named the Yankees’ director of scouting and, in 2011, promoted to the title of assistant general manager — a role he’d hold until being hired to lead the Angels’ baseball operations staff following the 2015 season.”

Mets’ legend baffled by continual rejection of team’s front office positions

Simeon Woods-Richardson

The New York Mets kicked off their offseason by announcing general manager Zack Scott wouldn’t be back with the team regardless of the outcome of his DUI case. As a result, they have been actively looking for a president of baseball operations and a general manager, too.

They have talked with at least ten people, including David Stearns, Billy Beane, Theo Epstein, Billy Eppler, Matt Arnold, Raquel Ferreira, Michael Girsch, Jean Afterman, Scott Harris, Brandon Gomes, and Mark Shapiro, about one of their top executive positions. They swung and missed with everyone, bafflingly.

Mets’ legend John Franco finds it hard to believe. “I’m scratching my head every day, when I read about people turning it down,” he said, per SNY, while explaining the position would be an ideal one because the team has an owner willing to spend.

Franco admitted, however, that some or most of the candidates may have passed on the chance because they like their current positions with their respective teams or because of family reasons.

Nobody wants to take on the Mets’ challenge

Franco, who leads the Mets in saves (276) and appearances (695), said at the fundraising gala for Joe Torre’s Safe At Home Foundation in midtown Manhattan that “there’s no place like New York. I was born and raised here, played here 15 years, was team captain. I’ve worked with the organization a little bit. There’s a new owner looking to spend.

“I speak to a lot of former players and teammates and we’re speechless on what’s going on and why it’s taking so long to get a president of baseball operations or a GM or even a manager. It shouldn’t be like that for a big-market team.”

The Mets have several holes to fill in the roster, particularly third base, center fielder, and the always-necessary pitching. “But you still have to have a face, a GM, and a manager. If you had a manager, maybe he could help out and recruit some players. That’s the difficult part right now,” Franco admitted.

Mets join race for star free agent center fielder

New York Mets interested in trading for Starling Marte.

This week, it was reported that the New York Yankees could be interested in free agent center fielder Starling Marte. However, as one of the top players at his position, it’s only logical that he generates buzz all around the league, and in the last couple of days, the New York Mets and Miami Marlins are said to be in on the dynamic outfielder.

In the past few hours, Brendan Kuty of NJ Advance Media had reported that Marte is, at the very least, on the Yankees’ radar. He also said that the players was under consideration in this year’s trade deadline.

However, the Mets are apparently now pushing for the speedy outfielder. Marte, 33, hit .310/.383/.458 in 2021, with a .841 OPS, 12 home runs, and 47 stolen bases between two teams.

The Mets want Marte, but have competition

One of those two clubs was the Oakland A’s, the team that acquired him as a rental at the deadline. The other organization is the Marlins, which oddly enough is interested in bringing him back as a free agent this offseason.

The Marlins and Marte talked about an extension, but when talks went nowhere, they decided to deal him, and got promising lefty Jesus Luzardo in return. But it appears that a long-term marriage is back on the table, and Marte has repeatedly said he loves Miami.

The Mets, however, are lurking. They, and “many others” according to MLB Network’s Jon Heyman, are also showing interest.

Center field is an area in which the Mets could use an improvement, especially defensively. Brandon Nimmo is the team center fielder and leadoff hitter, and he does a good job, but he is better suited at one of the corners with the glove. Signing Marte would mean that they slide Nimmo, probably to right field to cover for free agent Michael Conforto if he is not re-signed.